I’ve been a longtime admirer of Obsidian’s work, and I find it disappointing that GameSpot’s review of Avowed misses the mark. Obsidian has a proven record of transforming existing IPs into rich, immersive RPG experiences, a feat that deserves recognition rather than constant comparison to older titles. Rather than engaging in nuanced analysis, the review seems anchored in outdated comparisons, which ultimately undermines the game’s innovative achievements.

While opinions on game scoring are inherently subjective, assigning a 6 feels like an oversight that doesn’t reflect the creativity and effort behind Avowed. I believe it’s important to appreciate new titles for what they are—bold steps forward in a genre that thrives on innovation and evolution.

Obsidian’s commitment to delivering malleable and engaging experiences has long resonated with the RPG community, and it’s high time that reviews acknowledged these contributions rather than diminishing them through relentless comparison.