Having had plenty of time to think about this I'm finally ready to fully write up the best games of 2004. I'm a multiplatform gamer myself having played a good game on almost every platform out there so I'm gonna do this as a top 10 list. I, like most every non-journalist didn't get around to playing every single game that I'd like to have played. But of the contenders the only ones I didn't have time to get to at all were MGS 3, Katamari Damacy and GTA:SA, I had to unload my PS2 as i couldn't afford 5 platforms so when/if these games are ported to the x-box, GCN or something else then i'll be happy to try em.
10-Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell: Pandora Tommorrow- The single player here, was a bit of a rehash, but it was a rehash of something that i enjoyed quite a bit and then their was the multiplayer which was the clear focus of the game. The innovative 2 v 2 style of gameplay involving first person mercenaries facing off with 3rd person spies made this a real treat to play. The story was also good, solid Clancy stuff which made the single player a bunch of fun for me to play.
9-ESPN NCAA college hoops 2k5-I love basketball, particuarily good fundementally sound basketball. I mean a slam dunk is nice but a perfectly executed pick to get a 3 point shooter a clear shot at the basket is really beautiful too. NCAA 2k5 really puts this at the fore of the game and it's a lot more fun for it. While it's NBA cousins are gonna emphasizes the sizzle this one really emphasizes the substance of the coach's game of basketball. That's not to say you never dunk but flashy moves aren't at the heart of this game, good intelligent passing and play calling take that honor.
8-Burnout 3-Typically, I don't much care for driving games but yet for about 3 weeks Burnout 3 was all that I was playing as it really was that good. It really did a good job of two things, first and most obviously was that it really conveyed the sense of speed. Secondly, it made it into less of a problem to crash your car early in the race, you normally couldn't crash yourself out of a race by one or two in the early stages of the race. This meant that you could almost always come from behind to win this thing if you drove crazy good through the race. Not always but a whole lot of the time this could be achieved.
7-Chronicles of Riddick- I really wasn't expecting all that much out of this title and it really blew me away. The game, was based on a movie and it was both innovative and really good. This didn't wreak of a cheap, cash it in on a title but rather a game that recieved the same kind of attention that the film got and it showed. The atmosphere was just right for a game set in a prison, the graphics were really impressive, but most of all it was an innovative title that mixed fighting, stealth and shooting all in first person and tied it together with an interesting story about Riddick the surprisingly likable Vin Diesel character.
6-Doom 3-This game really seemed to wreak of love it or hate it, I for one loved it. The sense of atmosphere in the early levels of the game is so thick you could cut it with a knife. Later in the game the fear factor disappears and it becomes just a shooter, which to me isn't a negative thing. One of the best things i can say about this shooter is like most Id shooters before it, it wants you to be reacting not thinking and I think this is a very good thing. Maybe it's not gonna keep you engaged for long 12 hour sessions but it's a whole lot of fun to play for 1-2 hours at a time. It really gets the adreniline flowing unlike no other game in a while as it's good and clausterphobic. I understand all the complaints and they are valid for those people generally speaking but this one is one of the most intense shooters i've played all year as it's not pretentious like too many these days.
5-Rome:Total War- I've not played the TW series much before this year for a variety of reasons but wow what a way to kick it off for me. The combintion of strategic board game play, with tactical 3d battles on a grand scale makes it just a compelling game that you're gonna keep coming back to time and time again. The board game has that great "one more turn syndrome" that lead you to playing far longer than you originally anticipated and the gigantic battles will often test your wits in a variety of ways making you very nervous t times as to weather or not you're going to be able to manage a victory. Unlike a great many RTS games their are long stretches of battle where it's unclear whom has the upper hand and this chaotic feel really gives battles a real feel without being so real it's boring to play.
3-Halo 2 and Half-Life 2-Everyone seems to want a decision between these two games, which is better, which I liked more, which was more up my alley and the truth of it is that they were 2 purchases that perfectly complimented each other. Half-Life 2 had the best single player FPS campaign that I've experienced in a long time, with a awesome new implementation of physics leading to some interesting puzzles. However that being said, it's multiplayer was just missing something as Counter-Strike is already really tired and the Deathmatch combines a style of DM I don't like with a feeling of a bone being thrown to the community with some amateurish DM maps. Halo 2 on the other hand did the exact opposite providing a single player game that offered little new on the original's gameplay but it had some of the best multiplayer action i've seen in years. The ability of the game to keep the players of lesser skill and higher skill seperate makes it one of the best multiplayer games I've played in a long time as every match seems to come down to the wire.
2-Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic 2:The Sith Lords-On most testable, empirically judgeable scales KOTOR 2 doesn't have any right being this high on any list but games can't be judged solely on the empirical. KOTOR 2 was more fun than most of the other elite games on this year's list. The quality of the conversion of Star Wars to D&D added to the exceptionality of the story and the sense of the galaxy hanging on your choices makes KOTOR 2 one of the most fun, addicting games of 2004. Easily the best RPG from this year, and were it not for it's samey feeling I'd have named the Game of the year.
1-Ninja Gaiden-This game beats out several of the best games that I've ever played so choosing this one was something that took several months to decide on. But in the end the first great game to come out this year really was the best. I say this for two reasons, first of all this was the only game in the top 5 that wasn't a rehash, wasn't a sequel (I know their were ninja gaiden games when I was 9 years old but those aren't really the same). Secondly, and most importantly this game had the fewest problem areas, I could overlook problems in almost every other game in the top 5 and put them there but I don't have to do so with Ninja gaiden. Even the camera which bugged many never really got too cumbersome to me to prove more than a very mild annoyance at worst.
Log in to comment