People need to get over it. There both huge gimmicks. Neither add nor subtract from gameplay, most of all rumble. I cant remember ever playing a game where rumble was a gameplay feature. People talk like no rumble takes away from the realism *cough cough Scot Rubin, well "Im no soilder" but I'm petty sure when I get shot in the back, my hands arnt going to shake violently.

And with tilt, sure its cool when your racing and you can turn the thing like its a wheel, but come on. I don't want to hold what is essantial a rectangular **** and swing it around like Im using a sword. Its just plain dumb.